1After Abimelech, Tola the son of Puah, the son of Dodo, a man of Issachar, arose to save Israel. He lived in Shamir in the hill country of Ephraim. 2He judged Israel twenty-three years, and died, and was buried in Shamir.
3After him Jair, the Gileadite, arose. He judged Israel twenty-two years. 4He had thirty sons who rode on thirty donkey colts. They had thirty cities, which are called Havvoth Jair to this day, which are in the land of Gilead. 5Jair died, and was buried in Kamon.
6The children of Israel again did that which was evil in Yahweh’s sight, and served the Baals, the Ashtaroth, the gods of Syria, the gods of Sidon, the gods of Moab, the gods of the children of Ammon, and the gods of the Philistines. They abandoned Yahweh, and didn’t serve him. 7Yahweh’s anger burned against Israel, and he sold them into the hand of the Philistines and into the hand of the children of Ammon. 8They troubled and oppressed the children of Israel that year. For eighteen years they oppressed all the children of Israel that were beyond the Jordan in the land of the Amorites, which is in Gilead. 9The children of Ammon passed over the Jordan to fight also against Judah, and against Benjamin, and against the house of Ephraim, so that Israel was very distressed. 10The children of Israel cried to Yahweh, saying, “We have sinned against you, even because we have forsaken our God, and have served the Baals.”
11Yahweh said to the children of Israel, “Didn’t I save you from the Egyptians, and from the Amorites, from the children of Ammon, and from the Philistines? 12The Sidonians also, and the Amalekites, and the Maonites, oppressed you; and you cried to me, and I saved you out of their hand. 13Yet you have forsaken me and served other gods. Therefore I will save you no more. 14Go and cry to the gods which you have chosen. Let them save you in the time of your distress!”
15The children of Israel said to Yahweh, “We have sinned! Do to us whatever seems good to you; only deliver us, please, today.” 16They put away the foreign gods from among them and served Yahweh; and his soul was grieved for the misery of Israel.
17Then the children of Ammon were gathered together and encamped in Gilead. The children of Israel assembled themselves together and encamped in Mizpah. 18The people, the princes of Gilead, said to one another, “Who is the man who will begin to fight against the children of Ammon? He shall be head over all the inhabitants of Gilead.”
Judges 11 focuses on a "mighty man of valor" by the name of Jephthah, who was a Gileadite (v. 1). Since he was born of a prostitute he was disowned by his father's sons, his life looked dim. Yet the story tells us of his rise back to power and gratitude of the people of Israel to become their ruler. He is remembered, however, not for the difficulties in early life he had, or for his valor in war, leading Israel against their enemy, but for the story about a rash vow that he made to Yahweh, the God of Israel, of what he would perform for Yahweh should he win the battle. Did he truly kill his daughter as a sacrifice to Yahweh? There appear to be three different ways that we may understand this vow in Judges 11:30, 34-40.
1. Jephthah, in an immoral climate violated the law of God and killed his daughter since he has made a rash vow, and the daughter's remorse is over her death to come.
2. Jephthah, in an immoral climate did not violate the law of God, and even though he made this vow to God he chose not to perform the vow but committed her to life in the service of God.
3. Jephthah did not violate the law of God, but instead made a vow that should be understood as "or" so that he would either sacrifice whatever came out or what came out would be dedicated to the service of Yahweh. The girl spent two months in mourning because she would always be a virgin.
Let's look at each of these options.
1. For a vigorous defense of the view that Jephthah offered his daughter as a burnt offering in fulfillment of his vow may be found at George Foot Moore, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Judges, International Critical Commentary (New York: C. Scribner’s Sons, 1910), 304–305. He says, "The older Jewish and Christian interpreters, without exception, understood the words in their plain and natural sense; Jephthah fulfilled his vow by offering his daughter as a burnt-offering. George Foot Moore, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Judges, International Critical Commentary (New York: C. Scribner’s Sons, 1910), 304." Appearing to agree with Moore's conclusion, David Firth, says, quoting Baker, that modern persons might have difficulty with this any more than other moral issues present at the time in Israel. He says, "A moment’s reflection on the Jephthah story in Judges (Judg 10:6–12:7) quickly illustrates this point. The issue that troubles most modern readers is probably the sacrifice of his daughter (Judg 11:29-40), something that is reported but without any commentary at all.[26] But, as Baker argues,[27] the author of Judges does not moralize on a wide range of abuses prevalent among other peoples around Israel either, but expects that the way the story is told will speak for itself through the context provided and its aftermath. The narrator expects readers to discern why this behaviour is inappropriate without the need to make this explicit. [David G Firth (2020). (p. 8)." "New Studies in Biblical Theology: Including the Stranger: Foreigners in the Former Prophets." Retrieved from https://app.wordsearchbible.lifeway.com]
2. Some have interpreted Jephthah’s vow that whatever comes out of the doors as a clear intention to offer a human sacrifice (11:31). His surprise then is not that he had to sacrifice a human being, but that the unfortunate person was his daughter (11:34). The phrase "to meet me" seems to refer more appropriately to a human than to an animal, and it is difficult to see why Jephthah would mourn over fulfilling a vow to sacrifice an animal. However, In view of the rashness of the vow and the abhorrence of human sacrifice forbidden in Israel by Yahweh (Lev 18:21; 20:2; Deut 12:31; 18:10; Jer 19:5; Ezek 20:30, 31; 23:37, 39), it might have caused Jephthah to refrain from the sacrifice of his daughter, in spite of his vow to Yahweh. It is interesting that the text does not say that he actually killed his daughter, but only that he fulfilled his vow, somewhat unclear, followed by the words that "she was a virgin."
3. The third possible interpretation I find the most satisfying due to the ambiguity of the vow, the matter of the two months to mourn regarding the daughter's virginity, and not her death, and because the Hebrew grammar provides for an alternative. The first question, to me, is why would a ruler of the stature of Jephthah, who was declared a mighty man of valor and who asked for the help of Yahweh, offend God in a vow that would be contrary to unambiguous laws of Yahweh. The vow itself seems unclear if either a human or animal greets him first after a victory from Yahweh. Certainly, he indicates that he spoke too soon in expressing the vow, but would the idea of sacrifice be understood as a part of the vow?
Second, the response to the encounter with his daughter seems most unusual if her death by sacrifice is in view. Upon her greeting him he responds that she has brought him low and troubled him. This seems more for the loss of an heir than the loss of a daughter.
Third, he permits her request to spend two months mourning with her friends because of her virginity rather than being put to death. His response on her returning to her father for the fulfillment of the vow. The only statement is "she was a virgin." This seems to indicate a dedication to Yahweh in service, somewhat like Samuel, rather than being sacrificed on a pyre of wood.
Last of all, the Hebrew provides for the conjunction vav to be translated as "or" rather than "and," though the latter is more normal. But this is not a normal situation and the alternative of dedication to Yahweh in service, with husband or child, rather than dedication to Yahweh in death. The sense of the Hebrew, I believe, seems to be the following: “If you will indeed deliver the children of Ammon into my hand, then it shall be, that whatever comes out of the doors of my house to meet me when I return in peace from the children of Ammon, it shall be Yahweh’s, OR I will offer it up for a burnt offering.”1
I am pleased not only to be able to rely on Hebrew grammar for my conclusion, but the arguments of a Jewish Rabbi: Prof. Rabbi Jonathan Magonet, "Did Jephthah Actually Kill His Daughter?" ↩︎